Samsung SGH-i500 / SGH-i505
what is up with this design
And I question whether or not it has a speakerphone. Nowhere does it state this.
mk said:
That's a terrible design - who in the world would keep the unit swiveled with the main screen facing out just to see Caller ID? ...
That's not the reason the display swivels. It swivels so you turn it into a "tablet" form factor and use it like a regular PDA.
Ever used an i500? If you're using an app that requires lots of stylus use, it's kind of awkward to tap or draw on the top half of a clamshell device.
Plus, the i505 is a Palm OS 5.2 device, so no separate handwriting area. Can you imagine doing all your writing on an angled screen like that? The whole bottom half of the phone would just get in the way.
So with the i505, you just flip the screen around and - viola - it's a PDA. But y...
(continues)
HOWEVER, Caller ID exists for a reason - it's an incredibly popular feature. Any $400+ phone without it is worthless. Are you saying they can't put a display SOMEWHERE on this phone? Hard to believe. Check out Howards or pdaphonehome.com - just about everyone agrees the phone is crap without external display for Caller ID.
mk said:
... HOWEVER, Caller ID exists for a reason - it's an incredibly popular feature. Any $400+ phone without it is worthless. ... just about everyone agrees the phone is crap without external display for Caller ID.
Well, I agree that a caller-ID display is a great feature, and it would be nice if this had it, but I wouldn't say it's "crap" without it. 😉
Mainly I just wanted to point out that there is a reason it's not there. It's an engineering decision done (I believe) for the specific reason I listed earlier. They didn't just "forget" to add it. 😉
Are you saying they can't put a display SOMEWHERE on this phone?
Well, I already covered the usual spot. Ta...
(continues)
The user manual (available on the FCC site) clearly states that when you get a call, you open the phone, see the caller ID and press the green button to answer it (or the Reject button to not answer it).
There, now everybody's happy.
Personally, I think this phone seems to be the best Palm/phone combo yet. I have a Treo 180 but don't like the Treo 600 (bulky, screen has no cover and only 4096 colors). I was hoping the Samsung i505 would have a hi-res screen but I guess the battery couldn't take it.
Hats off to Samsung for supplying both a slim and larger capacity battery and a charger that will take both the phone and the spare battery at the same time. These people know what they're doing.
...
(continues)
Any guesses as to how long it will take Samsung to produce a follow-up phone with - guess what - an external LCD?
I have no problem opening the phone to see who's calling. I'd rather not have an external display bulking it up.
I'd also rather not have a poor-quality built-in camera bulking it up, but that's another story.
The functionality/memory/other more important stuff is what they would be looking for. Samsung is being smart in keeping the size down as well as the cost a bit im sure by not putting the caller ID on it. The reason is, cause they are looking at who their average consumer is....thats someone who wants the PDA and not a toy. If you want the convienience(sp?) of seeing if you want to answer the phone or not, you can still open it and look first. (as mentioned previously)
Think about it. The phone rings. I have to take it out of my clip/holder. I have to flip the phone open. I then have to push a button to answer it. All because I can't see who's calling. Lame. Very, very lame. They missed big time with this design. And by the way, every flip phone I've had allows me to answer the call when flipping it open. Are we now saying that we first have to look at the Caller ID after flipping open th...
(continues)
(continues)
Don't worry though, I won't say "told you so".
By the way - opening up a flip phone to see who's calling will cause you to answer the call. Unless you have "flip-to-open" turned off, which is a major nuisance. Kind of makes me question your knowledge of "your work in the industry and that's rarely a concern that arises".
Geez, where do these idiots come from!
As I understand your needs (after following this thread) you need external caller ID, and Palm OS on your phone.
Please correct or amend as appropriate.
The issue was, and still is, the convenience of external Caller ID. Not about it being a nuisance to open the phone. External Caller ID.
Before you jump into a conversation with pointless remarks, do your homework.
As I understand your needs (after reading this thread) you need external caller ID, and Palm OS on your phone.
Please correct or amend as appropriate.
This phone is in close to perfect (based on reasonable available technology). But, when I hear my phone, I quickly look to see who it is & whether I want to accept the call. I hate to think of not having external caller-id.
Given the option, take away the crappy camera & give me external caller-id.
Bluetooth is on my wish list, but I won't bitch about its absence.
Bottom line, Sprint & T-Mobile kind of suck in the SF Bay Area (I don't mean to start a debate), so I not switching to them, thus I need to wait for the next model.
What's more of a concern to those of us who use PDAs regularly to stay connected is a choice of carriers and bluetooth. Hopefully, the SD slot will support a Palm BT card that gives the ability to use a wireless headset. I also hope Samsung provides a CDMA version of this phone as T-Mobile/ATT/Cingular GSM networks SUCK when it comes to coverage.
I had a Samsung A400 for 18mo and always had to flip the phone open to see the caller ID... really, it's not a bi...
(continues)
Your description puts you into the PDA first, phone second category. I, along with a vast number of people, care about having a good quality phone first, then PDA functionality second. You're an IT guy, I'm a sales guy. I spend alot of time on the phone and don't care about Bluetooth or whizbang gadetry. I don't need a PDA to stay connected - that's what the PHONE is for. All I want is a place to look up phone numbers while on the road. And yes, I need to know who's calling before I answer the phone.
As for flipping the phone to see Caller ID, that is absolutely not an option for me. Ever. For any sales rep. The last thing you want to be doing is pl...
(continues)
I had the Samsung A400 for 18mo and went to plenty of meetings with it. I had a swivel case and could easily and discretely twist it and crack it open to see who's calling. Besides, if you are in a meeting and don't want to open a phone to check out who's calling, then why not wait until after the meeting to check out who called???? If an incoming call is so important that you'd interrupt a meeting to take it, then flip the damn thing open and look.
Also, pe...
(continues)
You also don't understand my line of work. And that's OK, I don't expect you to. But don't preach to me that my needs are incorrect - if I need Caller ID, and if I need to see who's calling while in a meeting without being disruptive, then CallerID is important.
And you are wrong - I'd gla...
(continues)
The above are MY requirements. This telephone meets MY expectations and I hope no one feels the need to preach to me as to what I should want.
Thanks for the i600 tip - but that's not an option - I don't care for an outdated version of Windows, nor do I need Windows. I need Palm OS. Or didn't you get that?
Why do some people have such a hard time reading and understanding these posts?
(continues)
Bye for now, looking forward to your next stupid remark.
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=5 »
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=80 »
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=123 »
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=173 »
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=175 »
http://www.palmone.com/us/products/smartphones/ »
http://www.kyocera-wireless.com/7100_phone/7100_phon ... »
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=146 »
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=119 »
http://www.palminfocenter.com/view_story.asp?ID=6599 »
Now STFU troll
Please print out all of my posts, read them, eat some crow, then go away.
by mk Feb 12, 2004, 6:20 AM
I think you need to read my post again as you seem to have missed the point.
Your description puts you into the PDA first, phone second category. I, along with a vast number of people, care about having a good quality phone first, then PDA functionality second. You're an IT guy, I'm a sales guy. I spend alot of time on the phone and don't care about Bluetooth or whizbang gadetry. I don't need a PDA to stay connected - that's what the PHONE is for. All I want is a place to look up phone numbers while on the road. And yes, I need to know who's calling before I answer the phone.
As for flipping the phone to see Caller ID, that is absolutely not an option for me. Ev...
(continues)
You really have a problem reading.
Go eat sh!t and don't come back till you've mastered Hook...
(continues)
It's funny - when people realize they're wrong, they typically resort to 2nd grade humor and swearing. But I am impressed - it looks like you did take my advice and started going back and reading my posts. Maybe you should have done that in the first place.
Is the valium kicking in yet?
Is the rod removed from your a## yet?
Now, go to Microsoft’s website, click on Mobile Devices, then click on Smartphone. This is a Microsoft product. Click on any of the links and it talks about Windows Mobile-Based Smartphones, the Windows Mobile-Based Smartphone community, etc.
Well that was fun, hope you learned something, it really couldn't be any clearer. Don’t look for any more responses from me, I’ve proven my point. Which is kind of silly, c...
(continues)
https://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=173 »
This tri-mode, 3G CDMA smartphone sports an innovative folder-style form factor that places the handwriting input pad and display on opposite halves of the phone. Key features include PalmOS 4.1, 1xRTT high-speed data, GPS positioning, color display, expansion card slot, external caller-ID display, stereo MP3 and video playback, speakerphone, and infrared.
Hope you didn't crap your pants waiting in anticipation you lil $***. 🤣 😛
mk said:
Anyone with any knowledge of mobile phones knows there's a distinction between a Smartphone (Windows) and PDA phone (Palm OS). I suggest you do your homework before you show your ignorance again.
Thanks for the i600 tip - but that's not an option - I don't care for an outdated version of Windows, nor do I need Windows. I need Palm OS. Or didn't you get that?
Oh and one more thing. The Smartphone label isn't just for windows devices you moron. That label has been used before MS ever introduced their own "Smartphone" OS powered device. PDA phone = (Palm OS)? Well PDA phone also = Windows Mobile 2003 PE / PPC, Symbian OS devices as well. 🤣 😛
NokiaTech is 150% correct. Smartphones are not just phones powered with some Microsoft mobile OS. Symbian OS, Palm OS, Linux (if there are any currently) powered phones are most definitely in the smartphone category. I suggest you read up on those links NokiaTech sent and educate yourself.
Second, you said it yourself... you want a good quality phone where you can store all of your contacts. Sounds like most of the phones out on the market now. My T610 does a pretty good job of that.
I never preached to you about what YOU wanted. You sat here and cried that this phone didn't come with an external caller ID. And while that is certainly a nice feature, the fact of t...
(continues)
And to prove the idiot that you are, look at your comment saying just about all phones can store contacts and make calls - you clearly either can't read or don't get it. A PDA or Smartphone can hold thousands more contact names/numbers than an ordinary phone and hotsynch rather than manually entering them. I have thousands of contacts that I want to download - hence, the need for a PDA phone. An ordinary cellphone can't do that. You wi...
(continues)
I doubt you have thousands of contacts to store on a phone. Based on your posts here, you are far to belligerent to be a successful salesman.
And no, I am not NokiaTech... although I'm flattered to be associated with someone who is obviously rather knowledgable about this industry.
But just to reiterate, because you obviously don't read well, I DO have thousands of contacts, which is why I need a Palm phone. Listen to me bonehead - I have over 3500 contacts in my database that I need on my phone. I've maintained that database for over 10 years, and as a successful salesman, I need access to these contacts at any time. So once again pinhead, you are wrong. Tell you what numbnuts- let's hook up sometime when you're in the area and I'll show you my database. Apparantly that's the only way you'll believe me when I say I need a phone that stores thousands of contacts...
(continues)
I think the i505 will be the new reigning smallest PDA phone in the world. Remember that it's a full PalmOS PDA phone. If it were any smaller, the stylus and touchscreen would be nearly useless.