LG VX-6100

I'm debating the two phones. I need a new one and like both of these. I've never had speakerphone capabilities and it looks like a nice feature, but don't know if I'd actually use it, since I've survived without it for so long.

I don't really care about the camera. My main concern is that given that I'm a bigger guy and have bigger hands, I'd like the phone to feel comfortable when I used it, and I'd like to easily be able to push the buttons.

Given that, has anybody had the opportunity to use both phones that could provide a comparison and a recommendation?

Thanks!